You should have been in my kitchen when I pulled this bread out of the oven – let’s just say happy is an understatement.
I know, I know – it’s kind of strange getting THAT excited over food, but I guess that it really should be no surprise coming from someone whose food blog was born after finding the perfect NY pizza dough.
It’s also become very apparent that yeast doughs are among my favorite things to make in the kitchen.
A few weeks ago, I baked this bread, which I named “Philadelphia Country bread” since it is a “natural starter” yeast bread (ie, meaning there was no commercial yeast used) made in the Philadelphia suburbs (I learned that everyone’s starter, also called sourdough or leavin, will be different based on the geographic area that you are based in). That bread was fabulous but the oven spring didn’t compare to that of this bread.
Now, surprisingly, the Tartine bread shown in this post uses the same basic formula that I used for the Philadelphia Country bread: that is, 750 g water, 200 g levain/starter, 2 g salt, and 1000 grams of flour (a 90/10 mixture of all purpose flour/whole wheat flours [King Arthur brand]).
What was different? Well, the technique I used was a little different for bulk rising the dough (I bulk proofed the dough next to a pot of simmering water to try and elevate the ambient temperature in my cool winter kitchen) and also for shaping the dough (I preshaped, let rest for 20 to 30 mins, and then did a final shape), and the starter I used was a little more mature, which from what I understand, can make the yeast more potent. I also used about 1 tablespoon of this mature starter to make a younger levain, which resulted in a much less sour bread. Finally, I’m unsure if I preheated both the top and bottom of my dutch oven last time but was sure to do so this time (I use a Combo Cooker by Lodge)
I also scored the bread a little differently, but I don’t believe that caused any major differences. I knew right away when I scored the dough, that this bread was different. You see, until now, scoring has always been difficult for me. The blade never really went through the dough very easily – it would tear the dough. I recall reading somewhere that could be because the dough was either underproofed or because it wasn’t shaped correctly.
There is a lot of great information on scoring here.
I scored this bread in a square pattern on top, and from what I recall, my cuts were almost at 90 degrees. It’s amazing that even the scoring on bread affect the final product, in this case, the shape.
In this video, at time 3:07, Chad Robertson demonstrates his shaping
technique. I used a similar folding technique that was shown in his book Tartine Bread, which is a little simpler.
At 75% hydration, this dough is fairly wet and so the crumb (ie, the inside of the bread) is nice and open with largish holes. In addition, this dough is stretched and folded, not machine mixed and so the danger of oxidizing or overmixing the dough is eliminated.
If you are a fan of Tartine bread, I encourage you to purchase Chad Robertson’s beautiful bread book called Tartine Bread. It was a wonderful addition to my library of bread books!!
If you are a Tartine bread fan, be sure to check out the fabulous blog called Tartine Bread Experiment!
If you need to troubleshoot, King Arthur has a fantastic troubleshooting guide
Please note that this recipe requires a dutch oven or combo cooker, a kitchen scale, and an established sourdough starter.
Recipe from Tartine Bread
Here’s more on the Tartine story:
- Kitchen scale
- Dutch oven or combo cooker
- Mature starter, 1 tablespoon
- all purpose flour, 100 g
- room temperature water (non-chlorinated), 100 g
- levain, 200 g
- lukewarm water (80 degrees), 700 g plus 50 g (75%)
- whole wheat flour, 100 g
- all purpose flour, 900 g (plus more for dividing and shaping)
- salt, 20 g
- In a glass jar, combine 1 tablespoon of starter with 100 g all purpose flour and 100 g of room temperature water (non-chlorinated [can be tap water than has left on counter for 24 hour to allow chlorine to dissipate] or spring water) and set aside covered (reserve and feed the rest of your starter for future use)
- Begin making the dough after the levain has risen (ie, it has doubled in height); for me, this is 8 to 10 hours after feeding (using a glass jar is helpful so you can mark the starting point and easily visualize the rise)
- In a large tub/bowl (I use a 6 gallon plastic food-grade tub), combine 700 g of 80 degree water and mix in 200 g leavin; mix well
- Add the whole wheat and all purpose flours and combine well into a shaggy mass with no bits of flour showing
- Cover and let rest for 40 minutes
- Add 50 g of water, and 20 g of salt, and squish to combine.
- Set the container in a warm area (78 to 82 degrees) (if wintertime, in oven with hot pan of water or next to stove near a pot of simmering water) for 3 to 4 hour bulk rise, and cover.
- During the bulk rise, perform of stretch and folds each 30 minutes. During the last hour, if needed, take care to fold more carefully so not to deflate the dough (I only perform 3 to 4 folds, during the first 2 hours and let the dough rise untouched during the last hour).
- After the dough has sufficiently proofed (20 to 30% rise), gently scoop the dough onto an un-floured countertop
- Divide the dough into 2 pieces, and lightly flour the top of each. Gently flip over and fold the dough (bottom up and top down) so that the floured surface is envelopes the loaf and then gently preshape into a round boule
- Let rest for 20 minutes. The edges should be round and thick (it's ok if it flattens a bit) but they should not taper off. If they do taper or flatten off, preshape again and let sit for another 20 minutes (this is equal to doing another set of folds during bulk rise)
- Final shaping (fold the dough into boules [Fold bottom third up, right side third over, left side third over, top third over and then roll the entire loaf over and gently pull toward you letting tension form the loaf further) and then place seam side up into bannetons which have been floured with a 50/50 mix of all purpose and rice flour)
- Final rise for 3 to 4 hours at 75 to 80 degrees or place in refrigerator for up to 12 hours (I always do the final proof in refrigerator) (if you do the final rise on counter, do the finger dent test to test for readiness)
- Preheat oven for 45 minutes at 500 degrees with a dutch oven or combo cooker inside the oven (ensure that plastic knob is removed if using dutch oven)
- Remove dough from banneton, and carefully place into bottom of dutch oven or combo cooker, score top in pattern of choice, and immediately reduce oven temperature to 450 degrees
- Place cover onto top of pot, and let steam for 20 minutes, then carefully remove lid with gloves and continue baking for another 20 to 30 minutes until chesnut colored
- Let cool on wire rack for at least 2 hours