These are my youngest daughter’s favorite cookie. She loves snickerdoodles and with good reason.I have read that some people experience problems with spreading while making snickerdoodles. I didn’t have such a problem, although I should mention that I didn’t bake the dough the same night that I made it. I’m not sure if this helped or not. Of course, baking with cold dough will help prevent spreading, but I took the dough out of the refrigerator while the oven warmed. The dough had warmed up a bit when it was baked and the cookies still stood up well.
One common problem that causes cookies to spread involves over-creaming the sugar and butter mixture. You should make sure that you scrape down the sides of the bowl to ensure that the ingredients are sufficiently mixed, but you shouldn’t cream them too much. A minute or 2 should suffice. Using a low-protein (10 to 12%) bread flour can also prevent spreading. I used King Arthur bread flour and it worked out very well.
Another problem that can cause cookies to spread are baking them at too low of a temperature. If you are using a home oven that is non-convection, try baking at 375 degrees instead of 350 degrees. Too low of a temperature can also dry out your cookies. I formed the dough into a log and sliced them at a thickness of about 3/8″, which is halfway between 1/4 inch and 1/2 inch.
Everyone likes soft snickerdoodles. It can be difficult for a beginner baker to visualize when the cookies are done because if they become browned, chances are that they will be overdone. Cookies tend to set up a bit more after they are taken out of the oven. To test if cookies are done, try lifting the edge of a cookie slightly. If it lifts off the cookie sheet, chances are that your cookies are done!
Here are more tips about common cookie mistakes
Ingredients
For the cookie dough:
- 1 cup butter , 8 ounces (room temperature)
- Granulated sugar , 10 oz (1.5 cups)
- Eggs , 2.5 oz (1 extra large egg) (room temperature)
- Vanilla extract , 1.5 teaspoons
- Bread or all-purpose flour , 10.5 oz (2.5 cups)
- Salt , 1/2 teaspoon
- Baking powder , 1 teaspoon
For the sugar topping:
- granulated sugar , 3.5 oz (1/2 cup)
- cinnamon , 1 tablespoon
Instructions
For the sugar topping:
- Combine the sugar and cinnamon and set aside until ready to bake.
For the cookie dough:
- In a large mixing bowl, beat the butter and sugar until combined (don't over-beat, as this will cause spreading), ensuring that you scrape down edges of bowl intermittently
- Add eggs and vanilla slowly and mix until combined
- Combine flour, salt, and baking powder and then gently stir in mixing bowl until combined
- Arrange dough into a log form and wrap with plastic wrap
- You may refrigerate until ready to use
- Slice log into 24 to 30 cookies (3/8 inch each) and dip into cinnamon-sugar mixture to coat
- Arrange on parchment-lined cookie sheet and bake at 350 (convection) or 375 (nonconvection) for 10 to 12 minutes.
Gayla says
Marie,
Your recipe says Baking powder, your comment says soda? is it powder or soda?
Marie says
Sorry for the confusion, the baking powder replaces baking soda plus cream of tarter in older recipes. So short answer is baking powder as shown in recipe.
J says
Usually Snickerdoodles have cream of tartar – any reason it’s omitted??
Thanks!
Marie says
the baking soda replaces the cream of tartar and baking soda used in older recipes 🙂Ella says
Actually there is a typo in Marie’s answer to this question. The correct answer is that baking POWDER replaces the baking soda and the cream of tartar in this recipe. This is because baking powder is baking soda and cream of tartar combined. Hope this helps and clears up any confusion.
Sharon Deyton says
Thanks. My recipe said to cream the butter and sugar for 3-5 min. That is probably why my cookies flattened. I’ve made them before and they never came out flat.
Marie says
I’m glad this helps. It happens to the best of us!