A combination of sponge cake, vanilla and chocolate pastry creams, rum syrup, whipped cream frosting, and nuts makes this Italian rum cake out of this world!
And so, here is my complete guide to making this amazing cake.
Table of Contents
Jump to:
- Table of Contents
- What is Italian rum cake?
- Overview of the process
- What is sponge cake?
- How to make the sponge cake (and top tips)
- Top tips for making sponge cake
- Making the pastry creams (vanilla and chocolate)
- Making the stabilized whipped cream frosting
- Making the rum syrup (and substitute)
- Assembling and decorating the cake
- Variations of this cake
- Make ahead tips and storage
- Italian Rum Cake
Italian birthday cake (Italian rum cake)
This amazing cake is better than most cakes you may find these days at the local bakery. My opinion of course. But, hopefully you may agree!
This cake is one of my weaknesses. If I let myself, I could probably eat the WHOLE thing. No kidding. Last day on earth? Yes, I’ll take a piece of Italian rum cake as part of my last meal. Heck, maybe even make it the entire meal!
Growing up, Italian rum cake was a must-have for every birthday celebration. We didn’t do chocolate cake, sheet cake, or any other cake. My family and most other Italian American families in the neighborhood had this kind of cake to celebrate birthdays.
Italian rum cake will always remind me of my old neighborhood in Philly; my mother; my Italian roots; my childhood….bittersweet memories for sure. I’m so glad that I’ve found a way to make it just as I like it because it seems to be harder and harder to find a good Italian rum cake!
I’ve heard that Wegman’s has an Italian rum cake now! People, make this cake – it will be better than Wegman’s – I promise (apologies to Wegmans – I really love Wegman’s!!)
What is Italian rum cake?
If you’re not familiar with this cake, let me introduce you (because I think you’ll really LOVE it)!
Italian rum cake is typically made of the following major components: (1) three layers of sponge cake that are soaked with a sweetened rum-flavored syrup, (2) then filled with layers of decadent vanilla and chocolate pastry cream (3) iced with a bakery style frosting, or stabilized whipped cream frosting and (4) then coated on sides with lots of crushed nuts (peanuts seemed popular in Philly OR sliced almonds in other areas of the Northeastern USA) on the outside.
So you have a combination of cake, vanilla and chocolate cream, frosting, booze, and nuts! Winning!
Overview of the process
Don’t be intimidated by the instructions – I have found that the real key is to make the cake in small steps over time.
Making the components over two or three days allows for easier assembly the morning of or night/day before the event/celebration. Of course, if you have a good helper, it can be made much quicker!
I suggest making the sponge cake first (and then freezing depending on when you want to assemble and serve the cake (see Make ahead tips and storage)
Then one or 2 days before you want to serve, make the pastry creams and the frosting and rum syrup.
The cake can be served a few hours after assembly but it is best served the following day to allow it to set.
What is sponge cake?
So what is a sponge cake anyway? A sponge cake is a type of foam cake, which is lighter and springier than a butter cake. According to Rose Levy Berembaum’s book, The Cake Bible, a sponge cake is similar to a genoise cake (which is another type of foam cake) but sponge cake has no added fat aside from the egg yolks.
Because sponge cakes don’t have a lot of fat, they are typically drizzled with syrup, in this case, a rum syrup!
The volume in your sponge cake depends on how the eggs are beaten, their temperature and the order in which the ingredients are added to your cake batter.
For more in depth reading about the different types of cakes, the reader is highly encouraged to see “Understanding Cakes” chapter of The Cake Bible. Is it an excellent book (although this recipe is not from Rose’s book, it is most definitely is a true sponge cake, just as Rose Levy Beranbaum describes according to the ratio of ingredients).
How to make the sponge cake (and top tips)
- Combine flour with salt in a small bowl and set aside.
- In a standing mixer, whip the egg whites on medium-low speed until foamy (not stiff) and then add the cream of tartar and continue mixing until the whites become opaque (the egg whites should not have ANY yolk at all in them or they will not whip up well – this is crucial for the cake to rise well).
- Add ½ cup sugar slowly to the side of the bowl and increase the speed of the mixer until soft but not stiff peaks form. Scrape the contents to another bowl and set aside.
- Using the same bowl, which is now empty, add the egg yolks and whip at high speed for 3 to 5 minutes until lightened in color and the mixture “ribbons” when the beaters are raised
- Slowly add the remaining sugar (ie, ½ cup), cold water, and vanilla into the egg yolks and mix until combined on low speed
- Sift the flour onto the egg yolk mixture in two additions, and stir gently with large spatula to combine.
- Gently but thoroughly fold in the whipped egg whites
- Transfer mixture to prepared pans, smooth tops if needed, and bake for about 20 minutes until cooked through. (the beauty of this cake is that even if your cake is slightly over baked the rum syrup, applied later, will moisten it very well!)
Top tips for making sponge cake
- Separate eggs while cold (this makes it easier to keep yolks and egg whites separate
- Ensure that your egg whites do not contain any traces of yolk (it helps to use separate bowls to inspect each new egg you separate before adding them to the other egg whites, otherwise you may taint the whole batch)
- Egg whites that have yolk in them will not whip well (egg white volume is vital to obtain optimal cake volume)
- Let the eggs come to room temperature after separating them. This helps to ensure that ingredients blend well.
- Gently but thoroughly fold the egg whites into the batter
- Weigh ingredients (grams or ounces) instead of measuring by volume (cups)
- Work quickly once egg whites are beaten so they don’t deflate
- Bake the cake immediately after the batter is mixed.
Making the pastry creams (vanilla and chocolate)
The process to make the vanilla and the chocolate pastry creams is quite similar and so to save time and space, only the chocolate version is shown.
Keep in mind that you’ll repeat this process again and omit the cocoa powder and add vanilla extra instead for your second filling.
The ingredients (chocolate pastry cream):
- Note that the heavy cream gets whipped separately and is added to the cream AFTER the pastry cream has been cooked and cooled. I do this just before I”m getting ready to assemble the cake.
- In a small bowl, add egg yolks and cornstarch. Whisk to blend and set aside
- In a medium saucepan, add milk, sugar, salt, and vanilla or chocolate (depending on if you are making the chocolate or the vanilla cream); heat until small bubbles form (scalded) and remove from heat.
- Temper eggs by adding small amounts (about ½ cup/4 ounces) of the hot milk mixture, a little at a time, while whisking very QUICKLY to prevent the eggs from curdling.
- After all of the milk mixture has been added into the eggs/cornstarch, return everything to the saucepan and cook over medium heat and stir constantly until thickened.
- The mixture can thickens quickly (depending on the heat)!! Stir fast and furious with whisk!
- Keep stirring until you see that it has stopped thickening or the thickening has slowed down.
- Cool the pastry cream and refrigerate until ready to use (this is when you do the last step below, adding the whipped cream).
- When ready to assemble the cake, whip heavy cream until soft peaks form (overbeating will cause it to turn to butter) and then fold together with cooled pastry cream (rewhip the pastry cream first if it has been refrigerated and/or it has firmed up a lot).
Making the stabilized whipped cream frosting
The Frosting Ingredients:
- Add gelatin and water to small sauce pan and heat on low until gelatin is dissolved; do not let the gelatin set
- In the meantime, begin to whip the cream and sugar until slightly thickened on medium speed
- Add the gelatin mixture in a slow stream and continue whipping
- Increase the mixer to very high and whip until firm.
Making the rum syrup (and substitute)
This is probably the easiest step: simply mix sugar, extract (or rum) and water in small saucepan and heat gently until sugar is dissolved and then cool.
You can apply to the sponge cakes with a large spoon or using a squeeze bottle if you have one.
I like to line up the cakes and apply the syrup while the parchment paper is still on bottom of cakes – makes it easier to move the cakes.
Rum extract substitution: you can use 2 tablespoons of dark rum OR 5 tablespoons of light rum for every 1 tablespoon of rum extract.
Assembling and decorating the cake
- Place a layer of sponge cake on cake plate or cake board if you have one.
- Soak cake layer with ⅓ of the rum syrup. (alternatively you can soak the layers all at once before starting to assemble cake).
- Top with all of the vanilla pastry cream.
- Place another layer of sponge on top of vanilla pastry cream.
- Soak cake layer with ⅓ of the rum syrup.
- Top with all of the chocolate pastry cream.
- Place the final layer of sponge cake on top of the chocolate pastry cream.
- Soak cake layer with the rest of the rum syrup.
- Apply frosting to top and sides of cake.
- Add nuts to the sides of cake and decorate top as you please!
Variations of this cake
- Nuts: I’ve seen a few versions of this cake online but with almonds instead of the peanuts. In Philadelphia, most if not all of the rum cakes that I’ve seen have the peanuts – I do wonder what area uses the almonds? It’s easy enough to substitute, but here in Philly, we’ve gotta have the peanuts. Feel free to use whatever nuts you’d like.
- Filling: Traditional filling for italian rum cake has been 1 layer of vanilla pastry cream and 1 layer of chocolate pastry cream. Of course, you can make it all vanilla or all chocolate. One reader mentioned they have had the cake with a layer of chocolate and a layer of raspberry filling..sounds delicious! I think it’d be fun to make a version with cannoli cream as filling one day! I’d probably skip the rum syrup and just drizzle with a sweetened vanilla syrup.
- Frosting: Finally, when I first started making this cake, I used a “bakery style frosting” whose recipe now appears in the recipe card notes section. I now use a stabilized whipped cream frosting, which is lighter in comparison Readers have also mentioned using a cream cheese frosting, which I think is more of a homestyle version.
- Rum syrup: If you are making the cake for children, consider using a vanilla sugar syrup (by simply leaving out the rum and adding a tablespoon of vanilla extract instead) instead of the rum syrup.
- Cake layers: Sponge cake is very traditional (and delicious) but if you want to use a butter cake base instead, feel free.
Make ahead tips and storage
Because this cake contains so many components, it can be time consuming to make. A suggested time table might be (just to give you an idea; this is super flexible of course):
- Make the sponge cake a few days to week/month before needed and freeze it.
- Make the pastry cream the morning before needed and refrigerate.
- Make the the rum syrup and frosting and assemble the cake the night before the celebration.
Storage: Frosting and fillings, about 5 days in the refrigerator. Cake layers can be frozen up to 3 months (wrap well in plastic wrap and place in freezer bags).
Store the Italian rum cake in the refrigerator until you are ready to serve it. Leftovers should also be stored in the refrigerator.
Some may ask if Italian rum cake can be frozen. I have successfully frozen leftover pieces of cake when I want to save some for a future date. The slices of cake freeze well and taste great! I wrap slices in plastic wrap and then place in a freezer bag. I have not attempted to freeze a whole cake.
More Cakes To Try:
More Italian Baking To Try:
Italian Rum Cake
Equipment
- 8-inch round cake pans (three total)
- parchment paper to line bottom of cake pans
- standing mixer or hand mixer
- cake board (I use 10-inch size) (helpful but not necessary)
Ingredients
Ingredients for the sponge cake:
- 1 cup unbleached all-purpose flour sift onto a sheet of waxed paper and then spoon into measuring cup and level to rim if not weighing
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 6 large eggs (separated into yolks and egg whites) separate when cold. Use when room temperature. Make sure egg whites do not contain any yolk!
- 1 cup superfine or regular sugar , divided
- 1 teaspoon cream of tartar
- 3 tablespoons water , cold
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Ingredients for frosting (stabilized whipped cream):
- 3 cups heavy cream
- ¾ cup powdered sugar
- 3 teaspoons unflavored gelatin
- 4 tbsp cold water
Ingredients for the vanilla pastry cream filling:
- 5 egg yolks
- ½ cup sugar
- 4 tablespoon cornstarch
- 1 cup milk
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/16 teaspoon salt
- ¼ cup heavy cream (whipped) NOTE: this gets mixed in AFTER the pastry cream has been cooked and chilled
Ingredients for the chocolate pastry cream filling:
- 5 egg yolks
- ½ cup sugar plus 2 tablespoons
- 4 tablespoon cornstarch
- 1 cup milk
- 2 tablespoons cocoa powder
- 1/16 teaspoon salt
- ¼ cup heavy cream (whipped) NOTE: this gets mixed in AFTER the pastry cream has been cooked and chilled.
Ingredients for the rum syrup:
- 1 cup water
- ½ cup sugar
- 1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon rum extract
Ingredients to assemble the cake:
- 2 cups crushed peanuts OR sliced almonds , lightly salted
- 8 inch cake board (optional)
Instructions
How to make the sponge cake:
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees and position rack in center of oven
- Grease inside of cake pans with butter and flour/cakespray and for added measure, line bottom of pans with parchment paper
- Combine flour with salt in a small bowl and set aside.
- In a standing mixer, whip the egg whites on medium-low speed until foamy (not stiff) and then add the cream of tartar and continue mixing until the whites become opaque
- Add ½ cup sugar slowly to the side of the bowl and increase the speed of the mixer until soft but not stiff peaks form. Scrape the contents to another bowl and set aside
- Using the same bowl, which is now empty, add the egg yolks and whip at high speed for 3 to 5 minutes until lightened in color and the mixture "ribbons" when the beaters are raised
- Slowly add the remaining sugar (ie, ½ cup), cold water, and vanilla into the egg yolks and mix until combined on low speed
- Sift the flour onto the egg yolks in two additions, and stir gently with large spatula to combine.
- Gently but thoroughly fold in the whipped egg whites
- Transfer mixture to prepared pans and bake for about 20 to 30 minutes until cooked through; using 3 pans, I only needed 20 minutes.
- Remove from oven, cool, and then run knife carefully around rim to loosen and invert to wire rack. After fully cooled, wrap and refrigerate or freeze.
How to make the pastry cream:
- Note that the heavy cream gets whipped separately and is added to the finished pastry cream AFTER it has been cooked and cooled. I do this just before I'm getting ready to assemble the cake.
- In a small bowl, add egg yolks and cornstarch. Whisk to blend and set aside
- In a medium saucepan, add milk, sugar, salt, and vanilla OR chocolate (depending on if you are making the chocolate or the vanilla cream [you will repeat all of these steps to make the other flavor)Heat until small bubbles form (scalded) and remove from heat.
- Temper eggs by adding small amounts (about ½ cup/4 ounces) of the hot milk mixture, a little at a time, while whisking very QUICKLY to prevent the eggs from curdling.
- After all of the milk mixture has been added into the eggs/cornstarch, return everything to the saucepan and cook over medium heat and stir constantly until thickened. The mixture thickens quickly (depending on how hight heat is)!! Stir fast and furious with whisk!Continue to heat and stir until it has stopped thickening.
- Cool the pastry cream and refrigerate until ready to use (this is when you do the last step below, adding the whipped cream). TIP: when folding in the whipped cream during next step, rewhip the pastry cream if it has been refrigerated to reduce the chance of lumpiness.
- When ready to assemble the cake, whip heavy cream until soft peaks form (overbeating will cause it to turn to butter) and then fold together with cooled pastry cream (rewhip the pastry cream first if it has been refrigerated and/or it has firmed up a lot).
- Repeat all these steps for other flavor (chocolate or vanilla).
How to make stabilized whipped cream
- Add gelatin and water to a small saucepan and heat gently just until the gelatin dissolves. Do not let the mixture set. If the gelatin cools too much you will have lumps or threads of gelatin in your whipped cream.
- Whip the cream and sugar using a standing mixer until the mixture is slightly thickened.
- Add the gelatin mixture slowly and then increase speed to high and continue whipping until the frosting is firm.
How to make the rum syrup:
- Combine all ingredients in a saucepan and heat over medium-high heat until sugar dissolves and then cool or store in refrigerator.
How to assemble the cake:
- Using a teaspoon or small squeeze bottle, distribute the rum syrup evenly over each of the three cake layers.
- Place one cake layer on the bottom of an 8- or 10-inch cake board or cake dish (you may spread some frosting between the dish and bottom layer to prevent the cake from shifting)
- Spread all of the vanilla pastry cream on top on the bottom layer and then top with another layer of sponge cake. Spread all of the chocolate pastry cream on top of middle layer and then top with final layer of sponge cake
- Frost cake, and add generous amount of crushed peanuts or sliced almonds to the sides of the cake. (if you have refrigerated the frosting (made ahead) you may have to rewhip it.
- Decorate the top if desired and refrigerate until serving.
Notes
- 28 ounces of powdered sugar (7 cups)
- 1 cup butter, room temperature
- 1 cup shortening
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- milk to thin frosting if needed
Add powdered sugar slowly, 1 cup at a time
Mix on medium-to-low speed to prevent air bubbles from forming
Add vanilla extract and mix to combine
Nutrition
Sources: Pastry cream adapted from Good Things by David; Sponge cake from Baking911; Bakery Frosting from My Madison Bistro
Stephanie Cavano says
Marie,
Beautiful…..I am married 51 years come July 31 (husband & I Italian on both sides) and we had a Traditional Italian Rum cake for our wedding cake. Our Bakeries in NY used crushed Walnuts. I have also worked in an Italian Bakery in NC (Owner was from NJ) and I love how precise your INSTRUCTIONS ARE. You are right, if you take your time, nothing is difficult about this recipe with a delish result. Thank you for sharing. Although I haven’t made this recipe yet, I’m giving you 5 STARS because, it is spot on right down to the stabilized vs bakery frosting with great instruction,
Marie says
Thanks Stephanie! Best wishes to you and your husband on many more beautiful years together!
Linda Roman says
Hi Marie, I wish I could give this 100 stars!!! LOVE it. I have made MANY over the years and always got compliments. This cake is just like Ciminari’s in So Philly, a cake we always had for every birthday growing up. Although it is labor intensive, it is worth EVERY minute of work. I am also a SO Philly transplant. Thank you SO much for this recipe. Warm wishes, Linda
Marie says
Awwwee, thanks Linda!! I’m really so glad you love it! It’s a really special cake, my favorite too!
Arthur Lupkowski says
Are you sure 4 Tbsp of cornstarch for pasty creme? I have to look for another recipe and the “creme” came out like silly putty. My cake deflated some and I did everything correct for cake but it still looks usable.
Marie says
Hi Arthur, yes, the pastry creme is on the thicker side because you are supposed to fold in the whipped cream afterwards, which loosens the consistency. it sounds like you haven’t completely made the recipe so I’m curious why you rated the cake recipe so poorly?
Arthur Lupkowski says
I made the cake. It tastes great. The pastry creme is wrong IMHO. Other recipes call for 2 TBSP not 4. If you want to delete my post and I will. Repost.
Marie says
Yes, it is intentionally very thick since I call for folding in whipped cream. I agree that alone (without the whipped cream) the pastry cream would absolutely be too thick – what’s crazy is that some people have said it’s too runny (if you read through all the comments….mine has never come runny) – I’m assuming those people haven’t cooked it long enough or maybe didn’t realize that some measure was off. I’m glad you enjoyed!
CakeMaker says
Sounds fabulous. I’ve been tasked to make a rum cake for a wedding, and I’m thinking of trying this. However, I probably won’t have access to a kitchen, the wedding is 5 hours away. Can I put this all together the day before, and transport? (3 cakes, 6, 8 & 10″) I’m concerned the cream will make the cakes unstable for transport, especially that far. If it’s better to assemble when we get there, I would have to take mixers for the whip cream and try to assemble in our hotel room. Would you try that or be safe and go without the cream?
Marie says
This is tough to answer because I’ve never done it and this is a big event so my gut instinct is to advise you not to chance it. If you are feeling daring, I would put together the night before so the cake and filling have settled and it is easier to slice. It is not a very tall cake, which most wedding cakes seem to be..
Shelley says
I have made this cake several times and it never disappoints. Once I made it with a strawberry and custard filling, another with a chocolate and custard filling. Both received rave reviews.
Question: how can I cut this back to only make a two layer cake?
Thank you
Shelley
Russ says
I finally got around to making this. It turned out wonderfully and was very well received by my family of rum cake critics. I may have to make this for all of our birthdays now. I went with the bakery icing and it was exactly what they wanted (and very tasty). We also like a good soaking with the rum drizzle, especially on the bottom layer (wet bottom!), so next time I’ll make more drizzle with more rum in it. It was suggested that there “should” be rum in the pastry cream, but I suspect if I use more rum syrup on the cake layers it will migrate onto/into the pastry cream layers overnight.
Chris W. says
OMG! This cake did not disappoint! Better than the bakery ones I’ve had recently! I grew up with Italian Rum birthday cakes for all birthdays and holidays. The last several cakes we had bought at the bakery have been so disappointing, cake has been dry and the prices have sky rocketed. I found this recipe and made it for my husband’s birthday! It was a huge success!! The Boston bakeries use slivered almonds which is my favorite.
Eva Marie says
We didn’t like nuts. Always substituted chocolate jimmies. South Philly bakeries all would do that. Looking forward to trying your recipe!
Disappointed says
Did everything right, beat the egg whites and yolks enough, but cake didn’t rise
Diane Paterson says
Your recipe calls for egg whites whipped into SOFT peaks. My cakes didn’t rise much. I bake a lot and can only think that at some point you must have to whip the whites into somewhat stiff peaks. Yes?
Marie says
The egg whites must be completely free of all yolks and it has happened to me as well – because of all the layers, it still comes out pretty good.
Beverly Pini says
Is there a way to convert this recipe into a rum log?
Marie says
Yes, I’m sure it can be done but I can’t give you specifics (batter per pan, time etc) since I haven’t tried
Michelle Salerno says
I can’t wait to try this! Thank you! My parents grew up right off of the Italian Market – so I was raised on Isgro’s or Termini Bros Italian Rum cakes for every birthday. Now I’m in FL – and there’s no such bakeries near me – I miss my Philly bakeries!
Shelley says
How do I store it in refridge after assembled?
Shelley says
This is the second time I am making this Rum Cake. The first one came out DELICIOUSLY! To my surprise! What I want to know is how to store it in the fridge? Everything says to wrap it in plastic and then foil. But what if it is already frosted? I don’t want to ruin the looks of it. I am making most of the parts on a Wednesday and hope to assemble it on Thursday to eat on Friday.
Thank you so much for this great recipe.
Patricia Jones says
I am eager to try this recipe. Can I make the rum syrup with rum instead of rum extract?
Marie says
Hi! Yes, instructions are in the recipe for using rum instead of the extract
rosemary merrill says
what to do if you only have 2 8″ cake pans……can you let the batter sit until the first layers are done???…put in refrig….????
Marie says
Yes, that’s what I would do….
Russ says
I grew up outside of Philly in Delco and we always had rum cakes for birthdays from Orlando’s in Collingdale. The original Orlando’s closed at least several decades ago and when it reopened, the rum cake was not the same (I believe the “new” place has also long since closed). I am not sure about the icing and I haven’t made it yet, but your recipe looks super promising so I definitely want to try it.
I found your recipe by searching for rum cake “peanuts” – because for us, it must have peanuts. It has gotten harder and harder to find places that use them though. It certainly sounds like it is an old Philly thing, but I also think some places switched over to almonds as peanut allergies became more of a concern. Often when we are able to find one made with peanuts, they aren’t salted (or salted enough) – which really is key because it cuts the sweetness a bit. We never have, but we always wonder if we could lightly spay the outside of those cakes with a salt solution! I believe Orlando’s also toasted their peanuts – either that or the peanuts they used were much more deeply roasted than what we typically buy in stores.
Since Orlando’s closed we’ve found a couple of decent approximations, but nothing really close except for one time at a brunch. We went back to the restaurant a few times but they didn’t have it again. We finally got someone there to tell us where they got their cakes, but when we got one it wasn’t the same. I don’t know if they did something different for the restaurant, if the restaurant had changed suppliers or if someone just gave us a name so we’d quit bugging them!
Marie says
I wonder if it was the same Orlando’s that was in Overbrook/West Philly? I used to LOVE their pineapple cheesecake sooo much!! I think you’ll love this cake – the frosting is simply a lightly sweetened and stabilized whipped cream but the notes section show another version for “bakery style frosting” – I don’t find a big difference between the two when making this cake because most of the flavor comes from the pastry cream, rum, and nuts in my opinions. Plus the whipped cream frosting saves a ton of calories….Hope you enjoy! I grew up in Philly right outside of Delco..
Russ says
Thanks for pointing out the bakery style frosting. I’ve had rum cakes with frosting that left an almost waxy coating in my mouth that I don’t care for at all. I suspect that may be due to the shortening in bakery-style frosting, so I am definitely going to try your stabilized whipped cream frosting first.
I’ve heard about Orlando’s in Overbrook, but I don’t think I’ve ever had anything from them. I wouldn’t be surprised if the two were related though. That’s why I was so excited when, about 10 years ago, I discovered that a relatively new friend was married to the daughter of one of the longtime bakers at Orlando’s in Overbrook. He had passed away years before, but I thought she or one of her many siblings might have a rum cake recipe from him. I was shocked to learn that they don’t have any of his recipes and none of them are interested in baking. I guess he never needed to bake at home and thus didn’t spark any interest.
Scott says
Thank you for sharing this recipe! Grew up in N.E. Philly and we’d always have Rilling’s Italian Cream cakes for B-Days. Your recipe pic looks almost identical to what I remember! *they only used peanuts too =)
Angela says
I have made this cake yet but I know it will be delicious. I can’t wait to make it.
M. Edela says
Hi, Our local Italian bakery – open for 50 years with one owner – has just closed so I’m very relieved to have found this recipe! Rum cakes are a part of every celebration in our house!! One question: I only have 2 8” cake pans. Can I bake 1/3 of the batter in one, 2/3” in the other and then slice the taller cake in half to create three layers or is there some magic to having crusts on top and bottom of each cake? Can’t wait to make this!!
Marie says
I would probably set aside some batter and bake 2 and then the last one, unless your pans are pretty deep.
Terese says
Fresh Market used to make this cake, it was a favorite of ours. This recipe is waaay more delicious! The tips and directions were perfect. I made the sponge cakes two days prior, and froze them. I also made the pastry creams that day. The next I assembled the cake to allow the flavors to meld. It was a huge hit! Many requests for the recipe. The recipe for the stabilized cream was very generous. I used only half the dark rum syrup (it looked like a lot) next time I will use all. Thank you so much for this fantastic recipe.
Marie says
That’s great! So glad you enjoyed and I hope many more will keep making this delicious cake for holidays and birthdays…it’s very hard to find for sure.
Caitlin says
I’m making this for a party tomorrow night. When I made the vanilla cream (before whipped cream addition) it’s really thick. Once it cooled enough to put a lid on and in the fridge it’s really really thick. Like no stirring hard. Did I do something wrong or is that what it’s like until you add the whipped cream? I was hoping to assemble this evening and wanted to make sure I had it right with enough time to remake if necessary.
Marie says
Nope, hard to say without seeing it but I will say it is pretty thick – the reason is we need something super thick as it will loosen up when you fold in the whipped cream. Otherwise, the cream would spill out and be too thin…
Caitlin says
I must of done something wrong. My chocolate was super lumpy. Tastes good but weird texture. And I also had trouble with the whipped icing. I have strands of gelatin in it. 🙁 Very frustrated as I bake a lot and had so much trouble with this.
Marie says
Ohhh, no I’m so sorry! I will add that the gelatin can not get too too cool or it will cause lumps in the whipped cream. That has happened to me and if it wasn’t clear, I’ll be sure to add that bit of caution. The lumpy cream I think could have been remedied by whipping it a bit more OR by letting the cream come to room temp before incorporating the whipped cream… Thanks so much for the feedback – it really does help to know the challenges as I can then add notes to the recipe.
Daniela says
Good recipe! I’m also a (first generation) Italian American, but I grew up in the Bronx. Our family loved rum cake- mostly for birthdays. The peanuts must definitely be a Philly thing because this is the first time I’ve ever seen it as an option. My entire family is from Italy, and we still go back regularly. Almonds, hazelnuts, pine nuts, pistachios are all very popular but peanuts just aren’t a thing there. Most Italian cakes are decorated with sliced almonds. I’m kind of glad about this because although I love peanuts my daughter is severely allergic. Thanks for the recipe!
Marie says
Yes agree 100% and my guess is that is why the Italians who came to philadelphia loved to use them (if that makes sense)? When my cousin from Italy came here several years ago he made sure to bring back (to Italy) a few jars of peanut butter because as you said it is definitely not a thing there but they do love it! Thanks for your comment and so glad you enjoyed the cake ❤️
Elisabeth says
Thanks for your post- had my first exp. with this cake as a child; Mother had brought a slice home from Sicilian friend’s dau. wedding. The vanilla creme had fine chopped pistachios, chocolate had fine chopped cherries & coated w sliced almonds on side atop frosting
Have looked most of adult life seeking this recipe. Began to think memory was off when search came to naught. So glad I was correct about the pistachios in the vanilla creme being traditional!
Sheila says
Hi! I am going to attempt to make this cake for my dad’s birthday. My grandmother always got him one, and she passed last December. We are from Massachusetts, and I have never seen one of these with peanuts on it-it has always been almonds! I was just chiming in because you said you’d wondered about the almonds.
Marie says
😊 sounds yummy! Hope you enjoy!
Dorothy says
I’m from Philly and almonds are used in Philly very much, although I do know some people who use peanuts. I agree that I haven’t heard if peanuts used in Italian recipes before. Sounds interesting though 🙂.
Marie says
Yes, my cousin from Italy brought peanut butter back to Italy after his visit (because apparently they don’t use peanut butter or peanuts in Italy, or at least where we are from) – my theory is that peanuts were such a novelty that a faction of Italian Americans replaced the almonds with peanuts. Not everyone but some for sure
Maria says
Isgro’s in South Philly was my family’s go to Italian rum cake bakery when I was a child. It was a staple at every birthday celebration. I’m too far away to buy them there now and so I am thrilled to find this recipe! Thank you!
Marie says
It’s my favorite cake recipe and I hope it becomes your favorite too!
Deborah Oliver says
This is my 1st time making a sponge by scratch. I just baked off the cakes and they are very flat. I noticed there is no baking powder of soda in the recipe. Are they suppose to be flat?
Marie says
No, but that’s happened to me as well and usually when layered the cake turns out ok. I’ve just updated this post with lots of info on getting more volume in your sponge cake – what I find most important is making sure the egg whites whip up to soft peaks (make sure no egg yolk is mixed in) and gently but thoroughly folding with the yolk mixture which should also be well mixed. Sponge cakes are leavened by the eggs so it’s important to get that volume
Carmelita DiPretoro says
So I offered to make an Italian rum cake for my friend’s mother’s birthday, even though I’ve never made one. I grew up in Philadelphia eating this cake at every holiday and was thrilled to find your food blog and this recipe. At first I couldn’t believe how similar our stories were. Actually, I was only a few sentences in when I remembered that the last time we got together for lunch you mentioned you had a food blog. How fortuitous that I happen to find it, LOL! The instructions seem very clear and I’m feeling pretty confident I can do this. I’ll be making this over the next couple days. Wish me luck!
Marie says
So did I:) …we need to meet for coffee or you can come over and we can make the cake together 😘 Marie (Elena)
Carmelita DiPretoro says
I love that idea!!